Dog People vs. Cat People: What Your Pet Preference Reveals About Your Personality

“Dogs come when they’re called; cats take a message and get back to you later.” This classic joke captures the playful stereotypes about pet lovers. But is there real science behind the idea that dog people and cat people have distinct personalities?

Spoiler alert: Yes.

From dating profiles to workplace icebreakers, the “dog person vs. cat person” question is a cultural staple. But beyond the memes and coffee mug slogans, psychologists have uncovered fascinating links between our pet preferences and our deepest personality traits. Over the past decade, studies have revealed that dog lovers and cat lovers differ in everything from social habits to creativity—and even how they view the world.

In this article, we’ll dive into three insightful studies to uncover:

Key personality differences between dog and cat people.
Why gender plays a surprising role in pet preferences.
How understanding these traits can improve your bond with pets and even reduce shelter surrenders.

Let’s settle the age-old debate—with data!

A cat and a dog sitting next to each other on a meadow.

Table of Contents

The Science Behind Pet Preferences: What Researchers Discovered

Study 1: Dominance and Competitiveness (Alba & Haslam, 2015)

Ever wonder why dog lovers often seem like natural leaders? This study tested whether dog people score higher on traits tied to dominance and hierarchy. Researchers hypothesized that dogs, being more submissive and eager to please, would appeal to individuals who thrive in structured, authority-driven environments.

Key Findings:

Dog people scored higher in social dominance orientation (SDO)—a preference for social hierarchies where some groups “lead” and others “follow.” Think of it as the personality trait that makes someone say, “There should be a clear pecking order.”
Dog people also scored higher in competitiveness, enjoying the thrill of outperforming others.
However, dog and cat people showed no differences in narcissism or everyday assertiveness.

Takeaway: Dog lovers may gravitate toward pets that mirror their desire for structure and loyalty, while cat lovers prefer companions that embody independence.

Study 2: The Big Five Personality Traits (Gosling et al., 2010)

This landmark study analyzed 4,565 participants using the Big Five model—the gold standard for measuring personality. The results painted a vivid picture of how dog and cat people navigate the world:

Trait	Dog People 🐶	Cat People 🐱
Extraversion	Higher ➔ Social butterflies	Lower ➔ Quiet thinkers
Agreeableness	Higher ➔ Team players	Lower ➔ Skeptical soloists
Conscientiousness	Higher ➔ Planner pros	Lower ➔ Go-with-the-flow
Neuroticism	Lower ➔ Chill vibes	Higher ➔ Emotionally tuned-in
Openness	Lower ➔ Tradition lovers	Higher ➔ Creative explorers

Takeaway: Dog lovers are outgoing, dependable, and love routines. Cat lovers? They’re creative, introspective, and unafraid to question the status quo.

Study 3: Narrow Traits and Gender Differences (Guastello et al., 2017)

This study zoomed in on 16 nuanced personality factors (e.g., warmth, abstract thinking) to reveal even deeper distinctions.

Key Findings:

Dog people: Scored higher in warmth (friendliness), liveliness (enthusiasm), rule-consciousness (respect for structure), and social boldness (comfort in crowds).
Cat people: Excelled in abstract thinking (imagination), self-reliance (independence), and emotional sensitivity (empathy).
Gender twist:
- Men who valued rules and order strongly preferred dogs.
- Women with high reasoning skills (linked to creativity) leaned toward cats.

Takeaway: Personality differences go far beyond “introvert vs. extrovert.” Even traits like intellectual curiosity shape whether you’ll bond with a Golden Retriever or a Siamese.

Key Personality Differences: Breaking It Down

Scrabble letters that say "Who are you".

1. Social Butterflies vs. Lone Wolves

Dog people are the life of the party. Their high extraversion means they thrive on social interaction—whether it’s chatting at the dog park or organizing a puppy playdate. Their agreeableness makes them empathetic listeners, which is why dogs (and humans!) find them so approachable. You’re the friend who texts, “Let’s meet at the dog-friendly café!”
Cat people cherish solitude. Their openness to experience drives them to explore art, philosophy, or niche hobbies—often in the company of a cat who’s equally content to do their own thing. You’re the one who cancels plans to binge-watch documentaries with your cat.

2. Rule-Followers vs. Free Spirits

Dog people’s conscientiousness isn’t just about keeping a tidy home—it’s about creating routines that benefit their pets like strict walk schedules, obedience training, and portion-controlled meals. As a dog owner you may have a color-coded pet schedule.
Cat people’s lower rule-consciousness reflects their “live and let live” philosophy. They’re less likely to stress over a cat ignoring commands or knocking over a vase. As one study participant joked, “Cats don’t have owners; they have roommates.” Your cat’s “schedule” is a mystery, and you’re okay with that.

3. Anxiety and Emotional Sensitivity

Cat people’s higher neuroticism doesn’t mean they’re unstable—it suggests they’re deeply empathetic and attuned to emotional nuances. This makes them excellent at reading their cat’s subtle cues (e.g., a flick of the tail or a slow blink). You may notice when your cat’s purr sounds “off” and immediately book a vet visit.
Dog people’s lower neuroticism aligns with their relaxed, optimistic outlook. They’re less likely to dwell on stressors, which is why they can laugh off a chewed-up shoe. Your dog destroys the couch, and you shrug, “Guess we needed a new one anyway!”

Gender Differences

Men: Rule-conscious men often prefer dogs, possibly because they align with traditional “masculine” traits like leadership. However, men who scored high in emotional sensitivity were more likely to prefer cats—a finding that challenges stereotypes about male pet owners.
Women: Intellectual, independent women (with high reasoning scores) gravitated toward cats. This aligns with cats’ reputation as “feminine” pets, though the study emphasizes it’s about personality, not gender norms.

Why This Matters for Pet Owners

Better Matches, Happier Pets
Adopting a pet that aligns with your personality leads to a stronger bond. For example:
- High-energy, outgoing owners → Border Collies or Labradors.
- Creative, introverted owners → Independent cats like Russian Blues or Maine Coons.
Reducing Shelter Surrenders
Many pets end up in shelters due to mismatched lifestyles. A conscientious, active person might struggle with a lazy cat, while a free-spirited artist might feel overwhelmed by a high-maintenance dog.
Improving Animal-Assisted Therapy
Hospitals and therapy centers could tailor interventions based on personality. An extroverted patient might heal better with a playful Lab, while an anxious patient could benefit from a calm, intuitive cat.
Strengthening Human-Animal Bonds
Understanding your personality helps you interpret your pet’s behavior more effectively. For example: Dog people’s rule-conscious nature makes them great at training and setting boundaries. Cat people’s emotional sensitivity helps them decode subtle feline cues (like tail flicks or ear twitches).
This mutual understanding deepens trust and reduces frustration.

Myths About Dog and Cat People

Myth: Cat people are antisocial.
Truth: They’re selective about socializing—prioritizing deep connections over small talk. (Study: Cat people score high in openness, which correlates with curiosity about others.)
Myth: Dog people are control freaks.
Truth: Their conscientiousness helps them create safe, structured environments—ideal for pack-oriented pets.
Myth: Cat lovers are “weird.”
Truth: Their creativity and open-mindedness make them innovators. Ever heard of the “Crazy Cat Lady” trope? Time to retire it.
Myth: Dog people are less intelligent.
Truth: One study found cat people scored slightly higher in reasoning, but dog people excelled in practical intelligence (e.g., problem-solving during training). Both groups have different types of smarts.

Conclusion: Embrace Your Pet Persona

Your pet preference is more than a quirky trait—it’s a reflection of how you navigate relationships, handle stress, and express creativity. Whether you’re a dog person who thrives on camaraderie or a cat person who treasures independence, there’s no “better” type—just different ways to experience love and companionship.

Owning a cat or dog yourself or thinking about going the next steps to get one? Visit our special cats and dogs (coming soon) sections to discover guides, recommendations and more fun facts!

References

Check out our most recent articles!

Do Bengal Cats Like Water? The Surprising Truth
Most cats flee from water, but Bengal cats often dive right in! Their wild Asian Leopard Cat ancestry gives them unique aquatic abilities that surprise many cat owners.
Science Cat Names: 250+ Perfect Scientific Names
Why settle for ordinary when your cat’s curiosity rivals that of the greatest scientists? Discover how scientific names celebrate both your feline’s intelligence and humanity’s most fascinating discoveries.
How to Keep Your Cat Entertained While at Work
Every morning brings the same heart-tugging scene: those pleading eyes watching you grab your keys. Learn how to transform your cat’s solo hours from boring waiting time into engaging adventure with proven entertainment strategies that work.
Do Cats Like Fans? Guide to Keeping Your Feline Cool
Curious whether your cat enjoys that cooling breeze? While some cats love gentle fan airflow, others prefer natural cooling methods. Discover your feline’s preferences and create the perfect summer comfort zone.
Calico Cat Female Names: 300+ Perfect Names
Calico cats aren’t just beautiful, they’re known for their distinctive personalities. Learn how to choose a name that celebrates both her looks and her legendary “calitude.”